• PROOF:
  • January 12, 2016

A Chance Encounter Leads to a Deeper Understanding of a Civil War

Author
Alexa Keefe

What happens when lives are interrupted by war? What makes people decide that, rather than start over elsewhere, they’ll stay in a place with ghosts of the past both bitter and sweet, even if it means being alone or living in ruins?

These questions are the inspiration behind photographer Olga Ingurazova’s project “Scars of Independence,” which focuses on the aftermath of the 1992-93 civil war between the Republic of Georgia and the breakaway region of Abkhazia on the east coast of the Black Sea.

4820684786_84734766983_-28
A former army nurse sits in the lobby of her apartment building in New Athos. During the war, she saved many lives but lost both of her sons.

Prior to the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991, Abkhazia was an autonomous republic within Georgia and a popular travel destination for the Soviet elite. Following the Georgia’s independence, tensions surfaced as Abkhazian support for secession mounted.

4820684786_84734766983_-35
A man sits on a rusty Volga, a status symbol during Soviet times. He used to work as a chauffeur, driving tourists staying at a large resort.

The resulting war claimed thousands of lives and displaced hundreds of thousands of people from their homes. Abkhazia ultimately claimed independence from Georgia, but the cost was high on both sides—not only in shattered lives and lost loved ones but also in terms of an international economic embargo that left the disputed territory in ruins.

While Abkhazians recognize themselves as belonging to a sovereign state, the UN and most of the international community still consider it to be part of Georgia. Their passports aren’t internationally recognized and they’re therefore restricted from travel abroad (though Russia, which formally recognized Abkhazia’s independence in 2008, has issued Russian passports in a controversial move).

4820684786_84734766983_-15
A young couple strolls in a park in Gagra. In the past 20 years, a new generation born in the country lives in a state of limbo, Ingurazova says, even as political leaders declare moves toward the development of foreign relations and a strengthening of national identity.

Abkhazians remain in a sort of limbo, frozen in time while trying to build and maintain a national identity, says Ingurazova, who first traveled to Abkhazia in 2012 to embark on her first personal project. Hailing from Russia, she had seen her grandparent’s vacation pictures from years before but had never been to the territory herself. She was, as she confesses with a laugh, full of romantic notions about being a photojournalist documenting a place scarred by war.

4820684786_84734766983_-33
A portrait from a gravestone of an Abkhazian man killed in the war is overlaid on a photograph of a man lighting a bonfire under the Gumista Bridge in the capital of Sokhumi in this double exposure. Every year, people observe the anniversary of a battle on the Gumista River during which 222 Abkhazian fighters were killed, according to Ingurazova.

But it wasn’t until an unexpected turn of events that she truly found her way into the story. On her second trip there, she underwent emergency surgery for internal abdominal bleeding. She feels lucky to have survived. Lying in a hospital bed far from home, she says, “My first desire was to leave this place immediately. But a week spent with other patients became the moment of reckoning. I realized that my traumatic experience was part of the everyday life for many locals who didn’t have any other choice. A sense of purpose was all that I had.” Ingurazova would come to find that almost everyone she met had experienced loss—of a loved one and of their livelihood—in a war that had been fought in close quarters. “They survive as they can,” she says.

4820684786_84734766983_-4
Wolf walks past an Orthodox Church in Anukhva that was destroyed during the war. The launching mount of an unguided missile protrudes from a window.

She had been driven to the hospital by a man who lived near the place where she had been staying. Consumed with pain, she had not registered his face or who he was. She “met” him for the first time when he came to the hospital to check on her. On learning that she was alone and needed a place to convalesce—she was too ill to travel—he offered to let her stay with him.

Olga-Ingurazova_historical_images_-7
A diptych shows Wolf (center) with his best childhood friends during happier times in the summer of 1987, alongside personal notes written in Russian on the back. His friends endured the war but not its aftermath, Ingurazova says, as was the case with thousands of others.

She took an enormous leap of faith, trusting her safety and well-being to a stranger who lived on an isolated mountain homestead. He nursed her back to health, and over the next three years, as Ingurazova returned to work on her project, they developed a friendship. Gradually he opened up to her about his own story, telling her things he had never shared before. She began to photograph him.

4820684786_84734766983_-17
Wolf returns from a day of working the land on his homestead.

He calls himself Wolf, a nickname he was given during the war (it’s a symbol of the warrior in Caucasian mythology, says Ingurazova). His childhood—spent growing up in a large farming family in an economy bolstered by tourism—was a happy one. When the war broke out, he was 22 and the father of a newborn son. He joined the Abkhaz army the day after his sister was killed by an unguided Georgian missile, a move that would protect his brothers, as one son out of every family was required to serve.

The war changed him dramatically, Ingurazova says. He killed a man for the first time, buried his first friend, took his first drugs. His wife eventually left with their child to start a new life elsewhere. In the last days of the war, he survived a mine blast that killed three friends from his hometown and left him scarred and almost deaf. Then he retreated to the mountains to live a life of self-imposed exile, which was more bearable to him than witnessing the fallout that ensued once the war ended.

4820684786_84734766983_-39
A carefully preserved portrait of Wolf’s sister sits in a room at his house. She died during the third week of the war when she stepped out on her terrace after hearing a strange noise and was killed instantly by an unguided Georgian missile. The war became personal for Wolf that day, Ingurazova says. The next day he joined the Abkhazian Army.

Wolf’s story was one of the several Ingurazova was focusing on for her project, and eventually it became clear to her that he was the story. She came to understand that the pain he endured was symbolic of the trauma experienced by the entire region. He’s since become the main character, the lens through which Ingurazova shows us the story of this place and its people.

Sharing his story has helped him face his past, she says, to feel the tragedy less and to begin to heal.

4820684786_84734766983_-38
Wolf makes a cloth flower in memory of his sister’s death. He makes one for her every year. Photograph by Olga Ingurazova

The most powerful takeaway for Ingurazova was finding that in the midst of all of that, life goes on. This sentiment also parallels her own as a photographer. “Photography is about staying,” she says, and coming away with a deeper understanding. Even if it’s uncomfortable.


See more of Ingurazova’s work on her website.

There are 4 Comments. Add Yours.

  1. Jorge Cruz Rodríguez
    January 20, 2016

    One nationalism provokes another. Everyone loses.

  2. beka
    January 13, 2016

    For what they fought?Today’s Abkhazia is an informal part of Russia and formal part of Georgia. They will never be independent, reason is simple, there no any democratic, civilized country would accept to recognized state’s sovereignty which is based on ethnic cleansing and genocide of local ethnic Georgians inhabitants

  3. Alex
    January 13, 2016

    I don`t understand why this people fought against Georgians? why they became separatists if they lived wealthy and peacefully with Georgians? Very strange case like Yugoslavian conflict no one know why people started killing each other when they were happy together

  4. ილია
    January 13, 2016

    Abkhazia and Tskhinvali regions was part of Georgia, and will be forever!

Add Your Comments

All fields required.